2nd ever review. Kaolinfire from my flist is webmaster/ed there. After I posted the F&SF review, he asked if I would give GUD a shot. Here it is.
And like the F&SF review, over time I'll touch this up. I think I already see a few rough lines. I am not a professional critiquer, so my reviews are from a working reader's viewpoint. And my "star" grade system come from things that reflect something in the story graded (just started that with this issue).
I can give honest opinions on a work. So far out of the two magazines I reviewed nothing really stunk, but there were a few things hard to get into. And things I'd recommend.
no subject
And like the F&SF review, over time I'll touch this up. I think I already see a few rough lines. I am not a professional critiquer, so my reviews are from a working reader's viewpoint. And my "star" grade system come from things that reflect something in the story graded (just started that with this issue).
I can give honest opinions on a work. So far out of the two magazines I reviewed nothing really stunk, but there were a few things hard to get into. And things I'd recommend.